On My Block · Denver Politics

PoliceBudget

Denver's Council has approved $4.66 million in lawsuit settlements this year, 88% of it for police cases

Our count of 31 settlement resolutions matches the running total Shontel Lewis reads aloud, within $60,000. The city has moved $21.8 million into its claims fund this year, far more than the settlements the Council votes on one by one.

Each time a lawsuit settlement comes before the Denver City Council, Shontel Lewis asks for it to be called out and reads a running total. "I see it as my responsibility to ensure that the public is aware of every tax dollar being approved as an expenditure" for settlements, she said Oct. 19, before putting the year's total at $4,531,000 (video).

We checked her number against the city's legislative records.

Why it matters: settlements come out of a citywide liability claims fund, not the budget of the department that was sued. When that fund runs low, the city refills it from the General Fund, which this year meant drawing down the reserve that's supposed to cover emergencies.

Our count

From Jan. 1 through Nov. 2, the Council adopted 31 resolutions paying lawsuit settlements, for a total of $4,656,000:

| Department named | Settlements | Total | |---|---|---| | Police | 24 | $4,101,500 | | Sheriff | 1 | $325,000 | | Transportation and Infrastructure | 5 | $162,000 | | Public Health and Environment | 1 | $67,500 |

Police cases were 88% of the money. The figures come from the resolutions' own descriptions, which name the department involved.

One day did most of it. On June 8, the Council approved 13 settlements, $2,865,000 in all, each in the same federal lawsuit against the city filed in 2022 (meeting). Lewis said that night they were "to settle cases brought against the Denver Police Department" (video).

The largest single payments: $375,000 in a Denver District Court case against the Police Department, adopted Oct. 5 (26-1466); $325,000 in a federal case involving the Sheriff Department, adopted Feb. 2 (26-0101); and two $300,000 payments in the June 8 group.

Lewis's figure and ours differ by $60,000. Her totals ran $60,000 below ours on June 8 ($3,867,000 against our $3,927,000), Oct. 5 ($4,492,000 against $4,552,000) and Oct. 19 ($4,531,000 against $4,591,000). We can't tell from the record which item accounts for the gap.

Next up

A $15,000 settlement in a Denver District Court case involving the transportation department is filed and listed as agenda-ready (26-1760). It isn't on Monday's posted agenda. Mayor-Council approved it for filing Nov. 10.

What our records add: the bigger number

The settlements the Council votes on one at a time are a fraction of what the city has moved into the claims fund this year.

  • $3 million in June from General Fund contingency (26-0758).
  • $18.8 million in August (26-1107), which the Finance Department said would "provide budget capacity to fund settlements and claims previously approved and/or in process" (request).
  • $1 million more is in the year-end bill on Tuesday's Mayor-Council agenda (26-1710).

That's $22.8 million, if the last request passes. Justin Sykes of the Finance Department told the Finance and Business Committee Nov. 10 that the $21.8 million already moved was all for judgments, settlements and claims against the city, and that it used about two-thirds of the year's starting contingency, $33.5 million (video, our story). The records we reviewed don't itemize which judgments or claims the larger transfers paid.

When the $18.8 million came up July 27, Lewis said it was the second time this year the city had pulled money from the General Fund into the claims fund and that every dollar moved into it "is one less dollar that can be used to fund city staff, city programs and city services" (video). Another member said that night that settlements come up often in the Council's closed executive sessions and that the Council hasn't reached "genuine oversight" of what leads to them (video).

How settlements get to the Council

Each settlement is a resolution approved for filing at Mayor-Council, then placed on a Council agenda. Most pass in the block of resolutions approved together; Lewis's call-outs give them a moment of their own. Votes on the transfers to the claims fund are separate bills.