Budget and Policy Committee

Monday, April 13, 2026, 1:30 p.m. (Denver time), City & County Building, Council Committee Room, Room 391 1437 Bannock Street

Committee: Budget and Policy Committee

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Budget and Policy Committee, chaired by Council Member Stacie Gilmore, heard a presentation from sponsors Amanda Sawyer and Shontel Lewis on a proposed charter change to Denver's budget process. The proposal would move Denver to an optional two-year (biennial) budget cycle, require a public community-engagement process to build a two-year strategic plan as the basis of the budget, simplify the budget timeline (removing the July 1 preliminary estimate and moving the September 15 date earlier), and add a charter definition of a balanced budget with a council role when revenues fall short of appropriations. Council members raised questions and concerns about the two-year cycle, effective timing after the 2027 election transition, the appropriate threshold for mid-year adjustments, and whether some changes could be done by ordinance rather than charter. City staff from Finance and the mayor's office provided feedback on reserves, capital funds, and collective bargaining. No votes were taken; sponsors said they would continue working with the Department of Finance on language and return to committee.

Transcript

0:08 Welcome back to this biweekly

0:09 meeting of the Budget and

0:09 Policy Committee of Denver

0:15 City Council. As for the

0:16 discussion Budget and Policy

0:22 Committee starts now,

0:34 a day. We have a great

0:35 presentation ahead of us.

0:42 Before we get started and

0:43 introductions, I don't see any

0:44 for participation. Is that

0:44 okay? Perfect. All right. And

0:46 we started my right.

0:46 Chris hinds Denver's

0:53 PRESIDENT. Complain Southwest

0:54 number district, things to get

0:58 a lot of them and us are just

0:59 turnovers district, charity,

0:59 one of your council members

1:00 even Taurus was Denver

1:01 district 3 Diana Romero

1:02 campus, southeast Denver

1:03 district 4. Would it be lucky

1:07 to 6, 7, for that to come from

1:11 rest, take it away. Alright,

1:12 Councilmember Gilmer, you want

1:14 to start small. Thank you.

1:17 Excited to be here. Back in

1:22 budget policy. It's awesome

1:23 working Sawyer Lewis on this

1:29 charter change The discussions

1:30 accountability within the

1:30 around more transparency and

1:33 Can we pull up the

1:33 budget. And so but see you.

1:36 presentation producer? Thank

1:44 on. We've got the agenda in

1:46 front of believe where will

1:51 have a council members Sawyer

1:53 go through. And many of these

1:55 topics and we're happy to

1:55 answer any questions that you

1:59 might have. I feel like we

2:00 have pretty much all the

2:04 different scenarios on how we

2:06 get this to you hopefully get

2:08 referred this summer so that

2:12 it can go to the vote on it.

2:14 And so looking at the city and

2:15 county of Denver, way that the

2:18 city structure is set up,

2:19 we're talking about the

2:21 general fund dollars, which if

2:22 you've been following

2:28 following along media lies

2:31 city lows of the Denver's

2:35 general why widely covered and

2:37 talked about the uses of the

2:38 general is what most people

2:42 think of as Denver's budget.

2:45 It's the largest city

2:47 financial funded sales tax

2:49 revenue and there's

2:50 flexibility in what it can be

2:53 spent for and how it can be

2:56 spent. Just remind folks in

3:01 costly 1.5 billion in 2024 man

3:04 close to this year as well.

3:05 Staff salaries benefits city

3:08 programs in general operations

3:10 and then I am going to turn

3:12 this over to COUNCILWOMAN

3:14 Slayer because she did a cut

3:16 and paste project on this one.

3:19 But I would hate not do it

3:20 justice will dig into it a

3:25 little bit. All started out

3:27 the required. It's just

3:29 Policies skews me is that it's

3:30 calendar year budget. It must

3:36 be balanced in must include

3:38 short and long-term planning

3:39 capital improvements. We're

3:40 all very aware right now. City

3:41 agencies should be talking to

3:44 each one of your council

3:48 offices around the six-year

3:49 capital improvement. Plan for

3:50 the city. That's both

3:52 department of Transportation,

3:53 Infrastructure and Denver

3:55 Parks and Rec. A quick

3:58 reminder, the Department of

3:59 Transportation Infrastructure

4:02 is responsible for building

4:03 everything in city. It's a

4:06 parks project still managed by

4:06 the Department of

4:08 Transportation and

4:10 Infrastructure. And so I think

4:11 that's important to

4:14 contingency must be at least

4:22 2% of the general fund signed

4:23 fund balance to is required.

4:25 And then of course, we the

4:27 state required taper,

4:29 emergency reserve COUNCILMAN

4:30 Sawyer. Do you want to chime

4:31 in any on this we'll mention

4:33 as you go through your mind to

4:40 Very good. Very good. So, you

4:41 know, the Constitution and a

4:43 charter that required

4:44 reserves. We have contingency

4:48 of the 2%. You can see the

4:50 contingency uses and then the

4:51 Unassigned Fund balance uses

4:54 as well and as council

4:55 members, I would hope that

4:57 we're all very, very well well

4:59 aware of but I think for the

5:01 public, it's important for

5:03 them really understand what

5:07 these different are allowed

5:14 for myself personally as a 3rd

5:18 term council I really think

5:20 that this will make City

5:21 Council stronger in elevating

5:22 the voices of the constituents

5:23 and the people that we

5:26 represent in. So that's one of

5:28 the main reasons that I'm

5:31 involved in this. And so I'm

5:32 gonna go ahead and turn it

5:33 over to through the rest of

5:39 the parts of Yeah. So when it

5:39 just when it comes to

5:40 contingencies isn't assigned

5:41 fund balance uses. I just want

5:45 to kind of give us a reference

5:46 point and the public a

5:48 reference point. So there are

5:49 3 and sort could include

5:50 savings accounts that we are

5:53 required to have by charter.

5:54 The first one is that

5:56 contingency fund. So in my 7

5:59 years here in the lowest it's

6:00 ever been is about 32 million

6:04 dollars is 2% of covered

6:05 expenditures and the assigned

6:07 fund balance has a goal of

6:09 15%. You can see the

6:12 unassigned fund balance by

6:13 going back that schedule. 100

6:14 and you can look at it. It's

6:17 and bold about two-thirds of

6:19 the way down and says ending

6:19 Budget Unassigned Fund There's

6:23 a dollar amount and then below

6:25 it there is a percentage

6:28 amount spend that percentage

6:29 should be at approximately

6:32 15%. That's our goal. And 15%

6:33 is where our fiscal rules

6:38 start to kick in. And then the

6:40 3rd one is our state require

6:40 Tabor Emergency Reserve, which

6:43 is 3% of them all covered

6:43 funds that that is required by

6:44 the state constitution must

6:49 always be there. So

6:51 contingency uses. I like to

6:53 explain the contingency all

6:54 council members of this might

6:54 have been through this a

6:56 couple of times. So you kind

6:58 of know what we need, it's

7:00 things like snowplows. So we

7:02 don't know how much is going

7:05 to snow in a year. It could be

7:07 like this year. The worst snow

7:10 year on record we have

7:11 budgeted think, you the

7:13 10 million dollars for snow

7:14 removal and not spend a dime

7:14 of it because it hasn't

7:16 snowed. So instead of doing it

7:19 that way, the way it works is

7:22 that take that money out of

7:23 contingency. So as a general

7:24 rule, the Department of

7:28 Finance doesn't like to any

7:29 supplemental is until closer

7:29 to the end of the year when

7:32 agency budgets are almost

7:34 fully expended. But those

7:35 dollars the way less you all

7:38 the way through the course of

7:40 the year. So something like

7:40 snow removal would be a

7:43 supplemental that would come

7:45 out of the contingency fund.

7:45 And in 2 of the Department of

7:47 Transportation and

7:49 Infrastructure Fund closer

7:51 towards the end of the year.

7:51 But that's why we keep those

7:52 contingency dollars in there

7:56 for things like appropriated

7:57 retirement payouts. You don't

7:58 know when somebody is going

7:59 retire or when somebody is

8:00 going to leave in you and they

8:03 have accumulated a full bank

8:04 of vacation days that we then

8:05 have to pay them out for

8:06 things like that that you just

8:09 like cannot budget for. So we

8:11 keep this contingency pile of

8:12 money to the for those

8:13 different kinds of things that

8:17 you can't budget and then

8:18 unassigned fund balance at 15%

8:21 is the goal threshold down?

8:25 Our fiscal rules were read and

8:27 then we looked 12 years ago,

8:28 15 years ago, and they sold.

8:31 So the fiscal rules have been

8:32 updated. 15 years feels like a

8:33 long time ago was actually

8:34 relatively recently in cities.

8:39 Speak so for funds above 15%.

8:43 Those are on an dollars

8:44 because we you know, we're

8:46 budgeting for it to hit 15% at

8:47 the end. If there are funds

8:49 above that 15%, those are on

8:51 appropriated dollars in the

8:53 charter actually says those

8:53 dollars then come back to city

8:56 Council to be re appropriated

8:57 or to be appropriated in the

8:58 first place. Not re

9:01 appropriated. Sorry, funds

9:02 between 10 and 15%. Get a

9:06 little bit hairy or so funds

9:09 meeting fund balance is

9:09 that are between when they

9:11 between 10 and 15%. That is

9:13 where our fiscal rules kick in

9:14 and there have to be

9:16 mitigating circumstances that

9:18 manage what that looks like.

9:21 So that would be things like

9:21 what we experienced at what

9:23 we're currently experiencing.

9:24 Things hiring freezes things

9:26 like furlough days. Those

9:31 different kinds of things that

9:33 preserve the dollars where

9:34 because we know our goal is to

9:36 get back up to 15%. So that's

9:40 kind of between 10 and 15%

9:42 below 10% is a real problem.

9:43 That is when layoffs could

9:45 again, that is what we saw

9:50 last year. And this is the the

9:51 kind concerned that council

9:51 PRESIDENT Sandoval and I

9:55 brought forward when we, you

9:56 know, got a call from the

9:58 Department of Finance at

9:58 Unfortunately, it looks like

9:59 we're going to do layoffs and

10:01 summer of 2025, and now is the

10:05 first time any of us had heard

10:06 about there being a

10:07 challenger. Concerns of this

10:07 is why council PRESIDENT

10:11 Sandoval and I moved forward

10:13 the the ordinance. Thank you

10:14 all for your support that just

10:15 passed. That will just be

10:15 quarterly financial reporting

10:19 for City council so that we

10:21 can see and track those trends

10:22 a little bit better across

10:24 time. So were not hit with a

10:28 surprise but when we have to

10:32 do layoffs that trigger is

10:33 that where our fund balance

10:38 was below 10% of the time? So

10:39 current budget timeline, you

10:40 all in you're about to see on

10:41 a slide coming up crime.

10:45 Incredibly busy slide. But

10:46 how's our proposed changes in

10:48 We've split that slide in the

10:49 appendix out into 2 different

10:50 sides. Year one and year to in

10:51 case of a little bit easier to

10:53 look at. But just wanted to

10:54 kind of make sure that, you

10:58 know, we level set by showing

10:59 what the what the budget to a

11:02 timeline looks like right now.

11:03 So you volunteered. I don't

11:04 need to explain it to you, but

11:04 for the public wanted to make

11:08 sure that we added it in there

11:09 and there benefits and

11:10 challenges to having an annual

11:14 budget as opposed our

11:15 proposal, which would be an

11:16 optional two-year moving to an

11:19 optional two-year budget. So

11:21 the biggest benefit when it

11:22 comes to having an annual

11:25 budget is flexibility. Miami

11:31 is it is easier to track. You

11:31 know, outcomes, potential

11:32 economic changes, all of those

11:36 different kinds of things in a

11:37 one-year looking one year out

11:38 that it is looking 2 years

11:41 out. So things like that.

11:43 Really are a that kind of

11:46 flexibility that that adds is

11:47 a real benefits. Say we can

11:48 quickly respond to economic

11:49 changes in those different

11:50 kinds of things. And add some

11:54 flexibility. There are some

11:55 challenges to it. And these

11:56 are the kind of the problems

11:59 that we're trying to address

12:01 So, you know, especially

12:02 people like our nonprofit

12:04 community partners, they hire

12:06 and staff based on the

12:07 contracts that they have with

12:09 the city and county of Denver.

12:12 And we know that budget

12:13 shortages contract get

12:14 reduced. So we have city

12:16 partners who have made plans

12:18 who have built their a

12:19 nonprofit organization in

12:22 partnership with the city

12:23 based on expectation of a set

12:24 dollar amount that did not

12:28 come. And so that means

12:29 reduced staffing for them and

12:29 all of those different kinds

12:33 of things. So being able to

12:33 work with our city partners to

12:34 say barring some sort of

12:38 thing. Incredibly dramatic

12:40 change in our economic

12:41 outlook. We borrow, you know,

12:42 this will be your budget this

12:43 year and this will be are

12:46 anticipated budget next year,

12:47 which allows our community

12:48 partners to just sort of staff

12:49 and plan on that a little bit

12:51 better and a little bit more

12:51 strategically, then they're

12:55 able to right now. I will also

12:57 point out as we've all lived,

12:58 capital improvement projects

12:59 take more than one year. I

13:02 don't think I've ever seen a

13:03 project in the city of Denver

13:03 that construction that took

13:05 less than a year to get done.

13:08 So being able to budget, you

13:09 know, a little bit longer and

13:10 sort of over 2 years because

13:11 capital stack sometimes

13:15 include operational dollars.

13:15 They sometimes include budget,

13:16 bond dollars. They sometimes

13:19 include capital dollars.

13:20 There's there's kind of a lot

13:23 that goes into creating a

13:24 capital Stack grant dollars

13:25 from all different levels of

13:28 governments organizations.

13:29 They're complicated, but they

13:32 never exist for one for solely

13:35 one year. And then, you know,

13:36 I think our biggest concern

13:38 for of why we started having

13:39 this conversation in the first

13:40 place is about the community

13:41 engagement piece as it comes

13:43 to developing the budget. The

13:44 only opportunity that our

13:47 residents truly have to have a

13:49 conversation about the

13:49 creation of the budget and

13:54 their tax dollars. Combs when

13:56 That city Council open up a

13:57 hearing for people to say

13:59 something about it. And that

14:01 hearing comes very late in the

14:01 process. You look at the

14:04 timeline one week before

14:09 budget is approved, so there's

14:11 you know, of course we try and

14:12 do as much community outreach

14:13 possible. And there's always

14:15 opportunity for people to come

14:16 to city council and public

14:18 comment and comment on

14:20 different things that they're

14:20 concerned about in our

14:21 community. But at the end of

14:25 the day, when it comes to the

14:26 budget, there's not a ton of

14:27 public engagement. I know a

14:28 few house members got together

14:29 last year and really did to

14:33 some targeted outreach and

14:34 engagement. And I've heard

14:35 nothing but positive feedback

14:36 from the community on being

14:39 included in that

14:40 conversations. Props to you to

14:43 set that up. The other sort of

14:44 challenge we're trying to

14:47 solve for is our time. Great.

14:52 If we could get 3 weeks and

14:54 split up that time a little

14:55 differently. So we could have

14:56 more than like 5 days to look

14:57 at 1000 page budget document

15:00 before a budget hearings. If

15:00 we could do our budget

15:04 hearings over 2 weeks, half

15:05 days instead days so that our

15:09 brains are not much by the end