On My Block · Denver Politics

NeighborhoodsCouncil results

Uptown property owners won't pay the St. Luke's streetscape assessment next year after the Council cut it to zero

Sitting as the Board of Equalization, the Council voted 10-0 to skip the 2027 charge. The district has about $500,000 in the bank, a board of two and, the city's own manager said, upkeep that's not up to standard.

Property owners in the St. Luke's Pedestrian Mall local maintenance district won't be charged for 2027. Sitting as the quasi-judicial Board of Equalization Monday night, Nov. 16, the Denver City Council voted to reduce the district's 2027 assessment to zero on a motion by Chris Hinds. The clerk announced 10 ayes (video).

The district covers the area bounded by Court Place, Park Avenue West, Clarkson Street, 18th Avenue and Logan Street, in District 9 and District 10. The city had proposed charging owners $176,067.37 for 2027, a 40% cut from this year (request, our story).

Why it matters: local maintenance districts charge nearby owners for streetscape extras the city doesn't normally provide, like brick sidewalks. Owners can protest, and the Council can raise or lower the charge. It rarely does, a city manager told the board.

What the city said

Nicholas Williams, a deputy manager in the Department of Transportation and Infrastructure who is managing the districts in an interim role, said the city received two protests for St. Luke's: one from an owner of about a quarter of the property in the district who believes the district isn't meeting expectations, and one about irrigation problems (video).

Williams told the board:

  • Denver has about 19 such districts. Each is entitled to five board members, four nominated through the boards and commissions process. St. Luke's board has one public member plus Williams, as the department's delegate (video).
  • The district has about $500,000 on hand, which is why the city proposed the 40% cut (video).
  • Over the next year, the department plans to fill out the boards and decide whether any districts should be dissolved. "If there's not interest in running these, we don't want them to continue collecting money from adjacent property owners" (video).

Asked by Darrell Watson whether the district is delivering the maintenance owners pay for, Williams said "currently not to the standard that should be expected" (video).

The protest

A representative of property owners, who spoke for them at the hearing, said the district was created in 2000 and that the city has never checked whether each property's benefit equals its assessment, which he said the law requires. He said that when owners asked for the district's finances this year, what they got included a $123,000 line item for professional services, not enough for owners, or the Council, to judge whether the charges are fair. He asked the Council to eliminate the assessment, citing the money in the bank (video). The same owners protested two years ago, Hinds said.

Hinds asked whether owners should be able to see bank statements and financial statements. Williams said they are public documents, any lack of transparency "was not intentional," and the city will comply with the Colorado Open Records Act (video).

Watson asked about the largest owner and was told a single LLC holds about 24% of the district. Williams said he believed no other maintenance district has one owner with that large a share, though he wasn't "100% confident" (video).

The vote

Brad Newman of the City Attorney's Office said the board can set the assessment amount, and that a zero-assessment ordinance for 2027 would then come to the Council (video).

Hinds, who said he lived in the district for years and uses a wheelchair, said one stretch of interrupted bricks has been dangerous for 20 years. He said he sees value in the district and is "not prepared" to consider dissolving it, but cited the missing financial documents and the board's thin membership in moving to cut 2027 to zero (video).

The city's written record of the vote hadn't been posted as of Tuesday morning.

The other protest that wasn't heard

The agenda revised Friday listed a second hearing, for one protest in the 32nd and Lowell district (our story). The final agenda listed only St. Luke's (agenda items), and the presiding officer announced at the start of the meeting that protests were filed for one district (video). Neither explained the change. The 32nd and Lowell item, 26-1768, still shows as "Agenda Ready."

What's next

The St. Luke's 2027 assessment bill, 26-1699, was on the Tuesday, Nov. 17, Mayor-Council agenda (meeting). The Council will see a zero-assessment version, according to the city attorney.