On My Block · Denver Politics

City financesCommittees

Department-head pay bill clears committee as its sponsor says the slide understated the General Fund cost

Amanda Sawyer told the Governance Committee the General Fund share should be closer to $750,000, not the $572,010 on HR's slide. Members questioned how bosses are kept above their deputies' pay and who reviews them.

The Denver City Council's Governance and Intergovernmental Relations Committee on Tuesday sent the bill that would reset pay for the city's 12 appointed department heads to the full Council. The vote was taken without a roll call (video, 26-1762).

Why it matters: the bill would raise each appointee's salary to a market rate on Jan. 1, then give automatic adjustments every four years starting in 2031 (bill). We reported the proposed salaries last week: raises of about 60% for the finance manager, 48% for the transportation director and 35% for the city attorney.

A correction from the sponsor

Amanda Sawyer, the bill's sponsor and the committee's chair, presented it with the city's human resources director, so vice chair Serena Gonzales-Gutierrez ran the meeting. HR's slide puts the 2027 cost at $822,346, with about $572,010 from the General Fund (presentation). Sawyer said the General Fund number was wrong and should be higher, about $750,000 by her estimate (video). Two salaries aren't General Fund costs, she said: the airport manager's is paid by the airport's enterprise fund and the human services manager's mostly by federal grants.

For 2027, agencies would cover the raises from vacancy savings in budgets already approved, and the cost would be built into later budgets, the presenters said (video).

"These are big numbers," Sawyer said. She said the positions hadn't been compared to the market in more than a decade; past raises didn't include a market adjustment (video).

Keeping bosses above their deputies

Five recommended salaries go above the market median because of what HR calls compression: a director earning about the same as, or less than, a top subordinate. HR's director said the trigger was a subordinate within about 6% of the director, and the fix added 10% to the subordinate's pay (video).

Gonzales-Gutierrez, who ran the meeting, used parks as the example. The manager makes about $170,000 and the closest subordinate about $197,000; the survey suggested about $216,000, and 10% over the subordinate gives about $217,000 (video). The bill sets parks at $170,523 today; the slide recommends $217,432.

The filed bill's text still says the one-time adjustment will "align salaries with the market median." It doesn't mention compression.

Other questions

  • Airport comparison. Kevin Flynn asked about the airport survey. The bill allows a survey of large commercial airports for that job, because few cities run one (video). The aviation job is open, and a recruiting firm is already working to fill it, the presenters said (video).
  • Performance reviews. The bill requires a yearly review of each appointee by the mayor or a designee. A member asked that the people who report to each director have a say in it (video). Gonzales-Gutierrez agreed (video). The bill says the review's form is up to the mayor.
  • More regular checks. Paul Kashmann said the city should study these salaries more often (video). The bill requires an HR market survey every four years.

No one signed up for public comment (video).

What's next

The bill needs two Council votes. HR's earlier timeline had them in the first two weeks of December, ahead of the Jan. 1 effective date.