Lawsuit seeks to block Amendment 87. Denver voters backed the income tax with 69%
Two state senators sued in Denver to stop the graduated income tax. Statewide it passed with 51.7%. The money is limited to areas where Denver leans on the state.
A lawsuit filed in Denver on Thursday asks a judge to stop Colorado from collecting any money under Amendment 87, the graduated state income tax voters approved Nov. 3. Denver voters backed it more strongly than the state did.
Advance Colorado filed the suit in state court on behalf of state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer of Weld County and Byron Pelton of Sterling, CPR News reported. The Colorado Sun also covered the filing.
Why it matters here: the measure's money is limited to health care, K-12 schools, higher education and child care. Those are areas where Denver leans on the state, from Denver Health to the child care items on the City Council's list of state priorities.
What the lawsuit argues
According to CPR:
- Two subjects in one measure. The suit says Amendment 87 broke the state constitution's single-subject rule by removing the Taxpayer's Bill of Rights flat-tax requirement from the constitution and also creating a graduated income tax in state law.
- The voter guide was wrong. It says tax tables in the state Blue Book told thousands of taxpayers they'd get a tax cut when they will actually pay more.
- The ask. Block the state from collecting any money under the measure.
The attorney general's office, which also speaks for Gov.-elect Phil Weiser, said it couldn't comment on a suit it hadn't reviewed, CPR reported. Chris deGruy Kennedy of the Bell Policy Center, one of the groups that proposed the measure, told CPR an earlier single-subject challenge failed in February. Advance Colorado also filed new ballot proposals Thursday aimed at reversing the measure.
How Denver voted
From the Denver Elections Division's unofficial report of 3 p.m. Nov. 6, the latest summary we found (report):
- Amendment 87: 208,262 yes (68.9%), 94,116 no (31.1%). Statewide it passed with 51.7%, CPR reported.
- Proposition 136, which would have capped the income tax rate at 4.4%: 86,965 yes (29.0%), 212,632 no (71.0%). Statewide, 52.8% rejected it, according to CPR.
Results aren't certified. Denver's certification is scheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 24.
How much money is at stake
Estimates in coverage differ. CPR reported the measure is expected to raise $2.7 billion a year. Earlier this month, Colorado Politics reported a projection of about $2 billion in its first year, and Gov. Jared Polis told budget writers that within three years "it all goes to Medicaid" (our story). The state is facing a gap of nearly $1.6 billion.
Advertisement
What the city has said
At the Council's Nov. 17 Governance Committee, the city's state lobbying team listed Amendment 87 as the one constitutional amendment that passed and said Proposition 136 was the one statutory measure that failed (video). They told members to expect funding and administrative bills next session "in response to the ballot measures that were passed" (video).
The Council's survey of members' state priorities includes child care, restoring past Medicaid coverage cuts and youth programs (slides). Two of those, child care and Medicaid, fall in areas Amendment 87 money can go. If a court blocks collection, those asks compete for a smaller pot.
Denver's own budget is tight too. The 2027 Long Bill is up for a final vote Monday, and the year-end bill introduced the same night spends the last of this year's contingency reserve (our story).
What's next
Tuesday, Nov. 24: Denver results are certified. Jan. 11, 2027: The legislature convenes. The court hasn't set a schedule for the lawsuit that we've seen.